Tuesday, 21 January 2014

Walter's Top 12 for 2013 - A Year of Lament

In The Storytelling Animal, Jonathan Gottschall writes that “hell is story-friendly.” He states: “Fiction may temporarily free us from our troubles, but it does so by ensnaring us in new sets of troubles – imaginary worlds of trouble and stress and woe.” Of course, when you think about it, we have always known this to be true. But my top movie choices for 2013 reminded me of that quote. In spite of being (in my opinion) very good films, so many of them seem very hard (the year of Gravity? Sorry…). Maybe I’m just getting more sensitive. In any case, be warned if you take these as recommended viewing.  This year really confirms for me that one of the most important purposes of good film is to help us lament.

First, runners up are Mud, Enough Said, Stories We Tell, Song for Marion, and The East. Then here's the top twelve:

 The Attack - In protest, I won't actually number this as part of my top 12 since I just can't accept its central premise. But I did appreciate watching the film, and it is in some ways a better film than my #2 choice about a similar theme. I appreciate what they were going for, but it went too far in trying to help us understand suicide bombers facing their desperation. 
11. Lore - This beautifully painful film makes you think about war in a new way and always sneaks in the question of how future generations will feel about the decisions we are making now. 

10. Populaire – Just to ensure that not all of my choices are heavy, this is the best of the foreign romantic comedies that Carol and I love to watch. Stylish and well made, this would be a good recommendation for those who want to start trying out some French films – even available on Netflix.

9. Gravity – I suspect that this film might have been higher on my list if I’d seen it in a theatre. It seems as though its real power comes from enabling the viewer to enter the terrifying and lonely experience it represents. The small screen just didn’t make that possible for me, and so the first two thirds of the movie were just sort of ok. But I really did appreciate key aspects of the last third and suspect that the ending would have been way better if I’d been drawn in deeper earlier. 

8. Disconnect – This is a painfully realistic film that – in the manner of Crash or Babel or Mammoth – weaves together stories of failed connection. Unsurprisingly these failed attempts are generally mediated by cellphones and computers. It seems the art world will keep screaming at us to wake up before it’s too late while we keep sliding down the slippery slope of virtual connectedness. Deeper, really, than the blame attributed to electronic communication is the foundational reality of an alienated culture. Whatever reasons are at fault, a lot of people are feeling alone, and this film does another good job at calling attention to our need to connect. 

7. Her -  I expected to like this more, but I didn't really care for Phoenix in the lead role (sorry, Vic, maybe it was the pants and mustache), and maybe the futuristic urban scene (filmed in Shanghai) was just too depressing for me. Yet, much of the film worked on a lot of levels. There was much to chew on psychologically and philosophically. Very interesting film.

6. Blue Jasmine – This was a very solid film by Woody Allen, who won me back last year with Midnight in Paris. This one, while very different, still finds me a fan. It’s a fascinating character study of how the narcissistic wife of a wealthy (and crooked) financier can seem incredibly competent in one context and utterly lost when that collapses. I suppose one could also view it as something of a metaphor for all those clinging onto a corrupt capitalist society who feel lost when that world starts to crumble. While the acting was all very talented, it’s a pity that Cate Blanchett fell into the very temptation to over-act that will probably get her an Oscar (as it has in the past for Streep and Portman). She could have been absolutely brilliant if she’d just reined it back a bit. (Do that many people like their emotion that over-played, or have I just lived for so long among more sane people than average? Excuse the rant.)

5. The Company You Keep – This film was a great mixture of plot, ideas and fine acting. The scene near the beginning when Sarandon’s character was being interviewed was worth the price of admission.Very solid, enjoyable film.

4.  Saving Mr. Banks – This was a surprise to me. I’d read a review that suggested it was boring and plain until a great speech by Disney about the power of imagination toward the end. I did appreciate that speech, but I’d also been engaged all the way through. I thought the Australian back story was played a little melodramatically, but was otherwise woven in perfectly.

3. Broken - One of the most painful of the lot, this film set in a British cul de sac seems to contain all that can go wrong in the suburban world surrounding an eleven year old girl. It's a cathartic lament on stolen innocence that notices the crucial role that courage and goodness still play. Some viewers might find this too painful and others may dislike the ending as "too much" - but I found it powerful and well done. Full review to follow soon.

2. The Reluctant Fundamentalist –  This is another powerful and difficult movie that I’ve reviewed earlier. Skillfully blending a leisurely life story with a tense stand-off following a kidnapping in Pakistan, this film makes a good case against the fundamentalism of capitalism.

1. Short Term 12 – This was a film I’d been waiting to see for a long time, and I was surprised that this one turned out a little less painful in its reality than I’d expected. But what an excellent film! The acting is consistently perfect down to the smallest role - so perfect it never looks like acting at all. I suspect that must mean the director (pretty much a newbie – Destin Cretton) must be amazing. The mixture of realism and workable narrative seems just right. The confrontation between the passionate Grace (Larson) and the experienced therapist/administrator was a perfect demonstration of the film’s ability to get the nuances right.
For the record, there are many films on your list, Vic, that I haven't seen that could have made it including 12 Years as a Slave and All Is Lost.  Not a bad year for films.


  1. And I note that I have not watched a single film in your top eleven which was not in my top twelve. I guess I also have some catching up to do.

  2. First, the above comment is false, as I forgot for a moment that in the end Saving Mr. Banks came in at thirteen on my list and thus did not make my top twelve.
    Second, I have now watched your second-favourite film of the year, which I enjoyed but would not have ranked as highly as you did (see comment under the film).

  3. Walter, I saw your favourite film of 2013 on the weekend and I completely agree with you. Loved it! It most likely would have made my top ten had I seen it earlier. Thanks for giving me the heads-up on this indie gem.

  4. Watched Disconnect last night. Not sure what I think about the ending, and it resembled Crash a little too closely, but this is my kind of film, so I loved this one too (and agree with, and appreciate, your mini-review). In my upcoming all-day film workshop, I will be talking about how films keep screaming at us to wake up about lots of things, but the results so far are not encouraging (which is why films like Wall-E and The Lego Movie can satirize consumerism without worrying about whether kids will stop demanding all the toys associated with them). I think the prophetic role of film is one of film's most important contributions, but the earth keeps motoring merrily toward its doom.

  5. Just watched disconnect and glad to see your comment here, Vic. While I agree with you both that it was like Crash, which I loved. It isn't screaming to me that I should disconnect from the internet...if that is what you are both kinda implying?? I feel that the movie said we can connect and /or we can disconnect. The message is use this media don't let it use us. I suggest societies next step would be education education and education and I think you'd agree.some wonderful things about this age we are living in and I for one love the movies I can see so easily

  6. Did I mention how much I don't like writing comments...it never works properly when I trytomake corrections

  7. Watched Her too this week...now that was disturbing. Put the two together and have a discussion night and I would love to come