You Can See Everything

I’m still planning to review Digger this week, but Digger is already old news (having disappeared from most theatres in less than two weeks). So let’s take a look at one of the biggest film stories of the year: a three-hour documentary that has become a huge box office hit while also generating an astonishing amount of conversation.

I have never seen any of the work of Canadian comedian, actor and filmmaker Nathan Fielder, or of his co-director Lance Oppenheim. I do, however, watch a lot of documentaries. Noting all the hype and the rave reviews, I therefore rushed out to see You Can See Everything during its first week of release. 

As I was watching this very unique and entertaining documentary, my first thought was “Nope, not a documentary. This is an anti-documentary.” By this I mean that the film breaks most of the rules that documentaries generally follow and also that by doing so it makes it clear how unreliable the documentary genre can be. This is especially striking given the title of the film and what seems, on the surface at least, to be a quest for truth. Indeed, the film could have been titled “What is truth?” or even “What is reality?” 

I’m not going to spoil the film’s twists, though I don’t believe the film deserves all the hush-hush big-reveal type of publicity as if there’s a big plot twist in which we discover that Elizabeth Holmes is really Darth Vader’s daughter. There is an unexpected development halfway through the film that works better if it’s a surprise, but it’s nothing that dramatic (I’ve seen many docs with much bigger reveals; they just don’t generate the hype). What that twist does do is highlight the fact that this documentary is carefully ‘staged’ and that everyone involved in the film (filmmakers, film-subjects and special guests) may be playing games with each other and with the viewers. Like I said, this is not a reliable documentary and I believe Fielder is intentionally encouraging viewers to never watch a documentary in the same way again. That is true of me - I’ve been reconsidering all seven of the docs I watched in the last month and wondering how the filmmakers did or did not influence the reliability of what they were showing us. Mini-spoiler: Fielder is not a reliable documentary filmmaker.

I actually felt quite uncomfortable with many of the scenes once I realized how unreliable You Can See Everything really was, partly because I felt manipulated but also because I felt that people in the film were exploiting each other in a cringe-worthy way. I won’t get into the Abbott and Costello scene, but for a number of reasons I wish it wasn’t in the film (my biggest complaint about many documentaries, namely that they are longer than they need to be, also applies to You Can See Everything, though it’s amazing that a documentary this long can hold our attention this well).

As for what the film is about, in case you haven’t heard: Elizabeth Holmes was convicted of a massive fraud involving her claims of having invented a device that could test blood with just one drop. You Can See Everything lets us into her home during the month before she begins her eleven-year (will never happen) prison sentence and then (with that twist) takes us into what happens during the first two years of the prison term. 

People expecting to discover the truth behind Holmes’s guilt or innocence will be disappointed. This film is much more interested in what’s going on in the minds of all involved (including Fielder) than in uncovering any great truth. Is anyone in the film even telling the truth about anything? Is it all just theatre? Since we don’t really know, does the film have something new to say (other than that filmmakers aren’t always trustworthy)?

If it sounds like I have a lot of concerns about You Can See Everything, I can assure you that is the case. But here’s the thing: I’m still giving it a four-star rating (out of four), just like most of the critics. Partly this is because the film is so original and so entertaining, but primarily it’s because it makes viewers think; indeed, it makes viewers think so hard that they need to spend hours afterwards talking about it with fellow viewers. I watched it alone, but still felt this need gnawing at me, so was relieved when many of my friends also rushed to the theatre to see the film (almost unheard of that so many friends would have watched the same film in such a short time). I LOVE discussing films (and TV shows) with friends, so the fact that You Can See Everything is getting people to do that more than any film in recent memory is alone worthy of high praise. 

So go out with your friends and watch this three-hour documentary and make sure you schedule another couple of hours for the debrief. ****

Comments

  1. Great review, thank you. I watched You Can See Everything at home on TV, and your point about it feeling like an anti-documentary really stayed with me. It made for a fascinating, if slightly unsettling, evening's viewing and plenty to talk about afterwards.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts